Best Frozen Pizzas: Top 5 Freezer Slices Most Recommended By Experts

The best frozen pizzas offer a perfect balance of convenience and taste, making them a go-to comfort food option. They should feature a flavorful, crispy crust that mimics the freshness of a traditional pizzeria, but that’s not always the case. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni, gourmet toppings, or unique flavors, the best frozen pizza options cater to a variety of palates, ensuring a satisfying meal without the hassle of delivery or takeout.

In the world of frozen pizzas, the best ones also excel in terms of quality ingredients. These pizzas often use premium cheeses, fresh vegetables, and high-quality meats to create a delicious and authentic taste. Whether you’re a fan of thin-crust perfection, deep-dish indulgence, or a unique fusion of flavors, the best frozen pizzas come in a diverse range of styles and options to cater to every pizza lover’s preferences.

These delicious frozen delights are prized for their consistency in delivering a mouthwatering, restaurant-quality experience right in the comfort of your home. They strike the ideal balance between convenience and flavor, making them a reliable choice for impromptu gatherings, quick meals, or late-night cravings. With the convenience of just popping them into the oven, grabbing a pie from the frozen aisle has become a beloved staple in many households, satisfying taste buds without sacrificing quality.

That being said, it’s important to know if the quick meal you’re planning is going to be a hit or a miss. With so many options, it can be hard to know before it’s too late if your selection will be flavorful and delicious or bland and stale. That’s why StudyFinds did the research for you and scoured the internet for expert rankings of the best frozen pizzas. This list includes the most frequently recommended pies, but if you have a can’t-miss favorite to share, be sure to drop it in the comments below!

Eating pizza with fork and knife — Cutting pizza (© EdNurg – stock.adobe.com)

The List: Best Frozen Pizza, According to Foodies

1. DiGiorno

As the familiar saying goes, “it’s not delivery, it’s DiGiorno!” While not to be confused with a restaurant pie, this freezer favorite is sure to satisfy in a pinch. “Is DiGiorno going to compete with that hot-from-the-oven slice or pie from your favorite pizza joint? Probably not,” notes Buzzfeed. “But they know exactly what they do best, and they do it really darn well. For a frozen pizza that’ll be fresh, fluffy, and just an overall joy to munch on, DiGiorno reigns supreme for a reason.”

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by DiGiorno (@digiorno)

“All stand for a veritable legend in the world of frozen pizzas. For a quick pizza fix, this is a great choice. While its flavors are a little weaker than our previous entries, when eaten hot out of the oven, you will not be disappointed with this classic frozen pizza brand,” says Restaurant Clicks.

“Where DiGiorno shone was its pillowy crust that really did ‘rise’ to great lengths. The cheese also melted and coated the entire surface flawlessly, resulting in ooey-gooey mozzarella strands worthy of an Instagram Reel,” adds Today.

2. Newman’s Own

If your favorite pizza joint is famed for its delicious thin crust, Newman’s Own is what you’ll want to keep stocked in your freezer. Reviewers across the internet were wowed by the crunch and flavor of the brand’s popular thin crust pizzas. “Newman’s Own is a great pick for when you want a thin and crispy base for your pizza,” says Delish. “All of our tasters noted how much they loved the crispiness, and how the pizza still felt substantial. We also loved the pepperoni in particular—with just one bite, you can tell that this is the real thing.”

two cheese pizza boxes against green background — Newman’s Own Pizza (newmansown.com)

“This pizza felt like a slightly fancier version of the classic thin-crust style of Tombstone and Red Baron,” adds NY Times. “The thin crust resembles those, but with some actual chew—the light, dynamic texture of a baked good rather than the slightly uncanny crumble of a crust seemingly printed by a machine.”

While delicious, the best part of a Newman’s Own pizza is arguably not the taste but the good done with every purchase. “The crust bakes up quickly and perfectly crisp. The pepperoni is also made from real beef and pork with no added nitrites (plus, there’s a generous portion on each slice),” says Food Network. “And, to top it all off, Newman’s Own is a brand that everyone can get behind, as 100% of net profits are donated to charities and nonprofits.”

3. Red Baron

A nostalgic favorite, Red Baron pizza might not be the first name that comes to mind when you think of a delicious frozen pizza. But numerous reviewers agree that this slice is more than worth the price of admission. “Be gone with your negativity. It may be one of the cheapest options, but Red Baron proves you don’t need expensive ingredients to deliver on flavor,” claims Today. “In fact, for a pie so well-priced, it didn’t skimp on cheese or sauce. Add a dash of Tabasco for a kick and enjoy a slice of ‘za that anyone, both young and old, can get behind.”

pizza box with pepperoni pizza — Red Baron Pizza

“Sometimes we want to feel nostalgic for our youth, complete with the pizza we would eat at school cafeterias and birthday parties. Red Baron’s Classic Crust pizza fits the bill. There’s a hearty amount of pepperoni and a solid ratio of sauce to cheese. Many of us agreed that eating this pie felt super nostalgic,” says Delish.

“Red Baron pizza has a lot going for it. This pizza was the closest to New York-style of all of them with its ooey-gooey cheese, moderately-thin crust, and expertly seasoned sauce,” adds Buzzfeed.

4. Amy’s

For a healthier choice, opt for an Amy’s pizza made with organic ingredients and no GMOs. But while it claims some health benefits, it doesn’t taste like a compromise. “Amy’s pizza features the classic combination of mozzarella, Parmesan, Fontina, and provolone,” lists Bon Appetit. “It also contains honey, most likely as a substitute for some sugar in the sauce (although it also contains some sugar, so who knows?), and red wine vinegar.”

pizza box with yellow flowers and cheese pizza — Amy’s Pizza

“When we were picking our favorite cheese pizzas, our most important factor was the quality of the cheese itself. Amy’s Cheese Pizza offered the most flavorful pie with a distinctly high quality cheese,” says Delish. “Our tasters also loved the sauce to cheese to crust ratio, which made for a balanced bite that still allowed the cheese to shine.”

“It’s not just Amy’s, it can be yours too! Although this cheese pizza is somewhat on the smaller side, it makes up for it with a delicious, strong taste. Its crust is wonderfully chewy and, combined with the rich tomato sauce, you have yourself a very satisfying and delightful pizza to enjoy,” adds Restaurant Clicks. “Being a cheese pizza, you should expect the cheese to be of top quality and that is just what it is. Melted across the whole pie, every bite of this pizza is the best.”

5. Tombstone

This pick is another that seems synonymous with pizza parties in elementary school. But believe it or not, this classic stands the test of time with great flavor at a great price. “Tombstone’s thin-crust pepperoni pizza was our favorite among the category of nostalgic, relatively inexpensive, thin-crust options,” says NY Times. “This pie screams sleepover pizza—delightful, if not wholesome—and does what it does well.”

pepperoni pizza box — Tombstone Pizza (goodnes.com)

While Tombstone offers the basic pepperoni and cheese pies, many reviewers say this is a pizza best enjoyed with plenty of toppings. “Tombstone is only as good as the ingredients on top of it, which is why I am a huge fan of the company’s Supreme variety (which, frankly, would blow most of this competition out of the oven),” claims Today.

“This pizza is an obvious winner. The pie has a lot of flavors going on, but they all complement each other really well, plus the sauce is on point and the crust is just the right amount of crispy,” adds MSN, recommending the Roadhouse Double Down Deluxe flavor as its overall top choice.

Sources:

Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links.

Tags: Pizza