Rottweiler puppy holding a bowl in his mouth

(© Rita Kochmarjova -

When you get a puppy, you want to make sure that they grow to be big and strong. That’s why you should know how to find the best puppy food for their nutritional requirements. When searching, try to look for things like antioxidants, extra vitamins and minerals, and a nutritional adequacy statement from the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) Formulation that’s appropriate for your puppy. In the meantime, the kibbles on our list provide a great jumping-off point to caring for your new pup.

As we mentioned, puppies need a specific formula when it comes to their food for good reason. A new study finds what you feed your puppy today may determine their health in the years to come. The findings suggest puppies should be eating more raw food because those who do end up with fewer allergies and skin issues later in life. 

Stick to high-quality puppy food because, just like humans, dogs eating a highly processed diet can lead to chronic disease. The question then becomes, what works best for them? Researchers find that dogs fed a meat-based diet consisting of raw red meat, organs, fish, eggs, and bones, as well as some vegetables and berries, or even potatoes or table scraps, were much less likely to exhibit gastrointestinal issues. 

So, given the importance of proper nutrition for growing dogs, how do we determine what to feed our fur babies? StudyFinds visited 10 of the leading expert websites to find the best puppy food most recommended across these sites. If we left out your go-to, let us know in the comments below!

Five yellow Labrador Retriever puppies (Photo by Bharathi Kannan on Unsplash)

The List: Best Puppy Food, According to Experts

1. Hill’s Science Diet Puppy Food

Hills is highly recommended by veterinarians, as its formulas are created by pet nutritionist experts. “The company does ongoing scientific testing to ensure its pet foods live up to their claims. This puppy food is suitable for dogs of all sizes and breeds—though the product is also available in large breed and small breed formulas—and it’s made using high-quality protein to help your young dog grow,” boasts Forbes.

Hill’s Science Diet Puppy Small Bites Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food


“Dr. Bryant is a fan of the puppy food from Hill’s Science Diet that is made with natural ingredients that help support strong bones, teeth, muscles, the brain and the immune system,” states The Dodo.

Large breed puppies have a lot of growing to do before becoming the humongous dogs you come to love. “The best puppy food for large breeds is one that supports the growth of their big bodies and brains, like this selection from Hill’s. If a natural puppy food formula is important to you, check out the natural ingredients including balanced whole grains and an assortment of vitamin and mineral supplements,” offers Petco.

2. Purina Pro Plan Puppy Formula

Prominent veterinarians recommend Purina Pro Plan’s puppy formula for dogs under one year. “It contains fish-oil-derived DHA for brain and vision development as well as live probiotics for digestive health and protein for building muscle,” says The Dodo.

Purina Pro Plan High Protein Puppy Food DHA Lamb & Rice Formula

This puppy food is formulated specifically for puppies that will weigh over 50 pounds. “If you’re trying to decide whether to get a puppy food with omega-3, a puppy food specifically for large breeds, or simply the best dog food with vitamins and minerals, why not choose one that does it all? It is packed with supplements for joint, bone, brain, vision, and immune support,” informs Petco.

Purina Pro Plan’s wet puppy food is a top choice if you have a picky eater. “This paté-style canned food comes in three different flavors—chicken, chicken and rice, and turkey—so you’re sure to find an option that your young dog will enjoy. Real meat and liver are the top two ingredients, giving the food an appealing smell and taste that your puppy will gobble up,” states Forbes.

3. The Farmer’s Dog

There are several subscription home-delivery services for dog food, which regularly send bags of fresh food directly to your door. “Dr. Judy Morgan, a veterinarian who specializes in integrative care, recommended The Farmer’s Dog, which she calls ‘TV dinners for dogs’ due to their palatability. Select’s social editor Sadhana Daruvuri feeds The Farmer’s Dog to her 1-year-old Maltipoo, Bandit, and he loves it. ‘I knew friends who tried it, and their dogs were all big fans, so I did a trial with Bandit and it was obvious he liked it way more than his kibble,’ she says. If you’re on a budget and have a large dog, this might not be a cost-effective option for you, but it may be more beneficial for owners of smaller dogs,” states NBC.

The Farmer’s Dog Wet Food (

All Farmer’s Dog recipes are 100 percent complete and balanced and formulated for puppies of all breed sizes. “Farmer’s Pork derives the bulk of its animal protein from fresh pork. Dry matter label analysis reveals the recipe contains 36% protein, 28% fat, and 28% estimated carbs… with a fat-to-protein ratio of about 78%. The entire product line is designed by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist (DACVN). Plus… each recipe is made with human-grade ingredients. A healthy feeding option for those able to afford the premium price. Highly recommended,” says Dog Food Advisor.

“The company asks each customer to fill out a series of questions about their dog’s age, breed, and weight as well as any food concerns they might have. Each diet — chicken, turkey, beef, or pork — is customized to your dog and shipped to your house, ready to serve. According to the Farmer’s Dog, their plans start at around $2 a day for the smallest dogs with few dietary restrictions — but the actual cost of any plan will depend on the specific information you provide when signing up,” says NY Mag.

4. Wellness Complete Health Dry Puppy Food

Deboned chicken, chicken meal, and salmon meal are the main proteins in this review. “The list of carbohydrates includes oatmeal, barley, peas, carrots, sweet potatoes, blueberries, apples, and flaxseed. It also contains probiotics and omega fatty acids from salmon meal and salmon oil. The nutritional breakdown is 29% protein, 18% fat, 4.5% fiber, and 450 kcal per cup,” says Business Insider.

Wellness Complete Health Dry Puppy Food, Chicken, Salmon & Oatmeal

Wellness Puppy is an exceptional formula. Contains just the right amount of calcium to make it safe for all puppy breeds. “Wellness Puppyn gets the bulk of its animal protein from fresh chicken and chicken meal. Our dry matter label analysis reveals the recipe contains 32% protein, 20% fat, and 40% estimated carbs… which produces a fat-to-protein ratio of about 62%,” informs Dog Food Advisor.

Wellness Complete Health provides immune system support and appetite stimulation for undernourished dogs. “This is an excellent option for pet parents looking to add whole grains to their puppy’s diet. Apart from oatmeal, it contains ground barley, a popular ancient grain in pet food. Salmon oil is the key ingredient for providing high levels of DHA and tomatoes provide a source of vitamin C and carotenoid lycopene, an essential antioxidant for a growing puppy,” states Wellness Pet Food.

5. Royal Canin Small Puppy Food

This formula from Royal Canin is specifically tailored to the nutritional needs of your small breed cuties, such as a Chihuahua, Shih Tzu, or Pomeranian. “It’s designed for puppies between two and 10-months-old that will be between nine and 22 pounds at maturity, and the kibble is smaller than most other foods, making it easier for small pups to chew,” says Forbes.

Royal Canin Size Health Nutrition Small Puppy Dry Dog Food

Royal Canin offers some of the most diverse dog food options on the market, making both dry and wet food for a variety of dog sizes, breeds, and dietary restrictions. “I feed my four-year-old Havachon, Bella, Royal Canin’s small-breed kibble after it was recommended by my veterinarian. I’ve noticed that Bella prefers this brand over others, which she would often leave half-eaten. Royal Canin also offers its dry food formula for medium and large breeds, as well as a puppy formula,” explains NBC.

If your small dog’s breed is a bit of a mystery, Royal Canin also makes food for small, medium, and large puppies that aren’t specific to their breeds. “Three of the vets we consulted recommend Royal Canin puppy foods. Zacharias raised six of her own dogs on Royal Canin, and Dr. Sara Ochoa, a Texas-based veterinarian and a veterinary consultant for, likes the brand because it is specifically formulated not only for a dog’s size but also for certain breeds, such as Chihuahuas or French bulldogs,” offers NY Mag

6. Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula

“This Blue Buffalo puppy product derives the majority of its meat protein from fresh chicken and chicken meal. Our dry matter label analysis reveals the recipe contains 30% protein, 18% fat and 44% estimated carbs… creating a fat-to-protein ratio of about 59%,” says Dog Food Advisor.

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Puppy Small Breed Dry Dog Food, Chicken and Oatmeal

Dr. Bryant also recommends the puppy formula from Blue Buffalo, which is made with natural ingredients enhanced with vitamins and minerals that help puppies grow strong muscles and bones and develop healthy immune systems,” says The Dodo.

Deboned chicken and chicken meal are the main protein sources in Blue Buffalo Life for puppies. “Carbohydrates include oatmeal, barley, peas, brown rice, carrots, and sweet potato. Healthy additions include probiotics and omega fatty acids from fish meal and fish oil. The food contains 29% protein, 17% fat, 5% fiber, and 415 kcal per cup,” offers Business Insider.

7. Merrick Grain Free Puppy Food

While it may seem like common knowledge, dogs actually have sensitive stomachs and certain ingredients should be avoided in their diets. “The experts we spoke to agree: Studies show that proteins like beef and chicken are among the most reported causes of allergies in dogs, so it’s important to look out for common signs of allergies — like excessive itching and vomiting — to figure out what works best for them, says Dr. Joe Wakshlag, professor of clinical nutrition and sports medicine and rehabilitation at Cornell College of Veterinary Medicine,” says NBC.

Merrick Premium Grain Free Dry Puppy Food, Wholesome And Natural Kibble With Real Texas Beef And Sweet Potato

Merrick Grain Free is full of nutrition for your pup. It delivers 67% of protein from animal sources to support developing muscles plus DHA to promote brain development. “Merrick Contains omega-3 and -6 fatty acids to nourish the skin and coat, glucosamine and chondroitin for healthy hips and joints, and no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives,” offers Business Insider.

This Merrick formula derives the bulk of its meat protein from fresh chicken. Dog Food Advisor offers a review, “This puppy food is a hit in our home! It’s got a good texture and is easily mixed in as a topper. It has a pleasant smell (for canned dog food) and you can see chunks of veggies throughout. The puppies are eager for meal times and clean their bowls. 5 stars!”

You might also be interested in:


Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations.

About Janelle Davis

Our Editorial Process

StudyFinds publishes digestible, agenda-free, transparent research summaries that are intended to inform the reader as well as stir civil, educated debate. We do not agree nor disagree with any of the studies we post, rather, we encourage our readers to debate the veracity of the findings themselves. All articles published on StudyFinds are vetted by our editors prior to publication and include links back to the source or corresponding journal article, if possible.

Our Editorial Team

Steve Fink


Chris Melore


Sophia Naughton

Associate Editor


  1. Nature gets it right says:

    How can an article say RAW FOOD is the best food to feed puppies…or any dog for that matter, yet the top 5 foods you are saying experts recommend are dry………experts?
    No wonder the human race is dying, sad we do the same to spices that rely on us to feed them. They don’t have a choice you guys can eat junk food your choice. They don’t have one…….

  2. Janet says:

    There is no such thing as healthy kibble. It’s like a human trying to live on the leftover charred food on the grill grates. Dogs thrive on a raw diet, the way nature intended…period. It’s not as easy as kibble but it’s worth it.

  3. Rob says:

    “The human race is dying??” We just hit 8 billion outraged and entitled idiots

  4. Nikole E Brasch says:

    I wonder how much you got paid to recommend these brands. All of which in a more recent study found they have forever chemicals at high rates in more than half the brands recommended.

  5. Heather says:

    I have researched all of this foods and none of them even come close to The Honest Kitchen. I raised my Goldendoodle on Royal Canin til we ended up at the vet with serious gastrointestinal issues. Did a lot of research and found this human grade food and he LOVES IT!! I have no regrets and don’t worry everytime I am feeding him that I’m not sure what is in it.

  6. Rhonda says:

    Totally disagree Blue Buffalo recalled how many times Check out Fromm

  7. Terrie Ford says:

    Really?!? Read the ingredients. These are some of the least desirable brands to feed your dog!

  8. candace says:

    Gentle Giants should have definitely made the list

  9. Jc says:

    This is a good one. You have the worse 3 brands on top. There foods typically cause gastro issues, nutrient deficiency, and other issues. They also are supposedly scientifically tested which is even better since the scientists are hired and heavily paid by the individual companies to come up with this bs. I’d rather feed my dog literal garbage from a trash can then these options. Interesting how many companies are willing to take a check to write this bs and pass it as facts

  10. DogDaycareOwner says:

    I literally gasped when I saw Beneful as number one. BENEFUL???!!! This is one of THE WORST brands of food to feed your dog!!! It’s full of by-products, synthetic flavoring, soy, corn and even corn gluten!!! You might as well feed your dog McDonald’s!! Whoever wrote this article is NOT an expert and clearly it was sponsored by one of the big box pet stores.

    Please please please look into non-big box brands like Fromm, Farina, Orijen, SquarePet, Taste of the Wild, etc. At first glance they may seem more expensive. In reality, you can feed almost half the amount than the big box foods because they’re packed full of nutrition and not fillers. Some of them even have frequent buyer programs. Added bonus… Your dog will have smaller poops!

  11. Marie says:

    This HAS to be a joke, right?!? No one with an iota of knowledge about canine nutrition would feed this crap, with the possible exception of Wellness.

    Royal Canin is the biggest hoax ever perpetuated on animal owners. Look at the ingredients; there is virtually NO DIFFERENCE, just a different dog (or cat) on the bag.

    The others on your list have had multiple recalls due to contamination issues that, let us not forget, killed many pets.

    Fromm and Honest Kitchen never make these “best” lists because they are not big-dollar advertisers. Always follow the money on these pathetically useless lists.

  12. Alyssa says:

    Beneful only got a harsh talking to about poisoning dogs from toxic ingredients several years ago. No laws were put into effect and they were shady when inspectors came into their facilities. Inspectors weren’t even allowed to take photos while there. Because of that it’s advised to stay away from Beneful. The only good thing about this food is it’s cheap.