
(Credit: Marijana Batinic/Shutterstock)
JERUSALEM — While most of us learned that the wheel was invented around 3500 BCE for transportation, a groundbreaking discovery in Israel suggests we need to roll back our understanding of rotational technology by several thousand years. Researchers have unearthed over 100 perforated stone discs from a 12,000-year-old village that may represent humanity’s first experiments with wheel-like objects – not for moving carts or chariots, but for spinning thread.
The archaeological site of Nahal Ein-Gev II, located near the Sea of Galilee in Israel, has yielded an extraordinary collection of 113 limestone pebbles, each carefully drilled through the center. While such perforated stones are not uncommon in ancient sites, this collection is special because of its age, quantity, and the careful way the holes were made. These weren’t just random rocks with holes – they appeared to be carefully selected and modified tools that served a specific purpose.
Think of them as prehistoric fidget spinners but with a practical application. The researchers believe these perforated stones served as spindle whorls – weighted discs that, when attached to a wooden stick, helped transform plant or animal fibers into thread through spinning. It’s similar to how a modern spinning wheel works, just more primitive and portable.
The research team, led by Talia Yashuv and Leore Grosman from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, used cutting-edge 3D scanning technology to analyze these ancient artifacts in unprecedented detail. They discovered that despite their seemingly simple appearance, these tools showed remarkable sophistication in their design and creation.
The stones weren’t just randomly selected – most were made from soft limestone, weighed between 1-34 grams (with most falling between 2-15 grams), and had holes drilled precisely through their centers. This central positioning was crucial for the spinning process to work effectively, much like how a modern fidget spinner needs perfect balance to rotate smoothly.
What’s particularly fascinating is how these holes were created. In 95% of the stones, the holes were drilled from both sides to meet in the middle – a more complex but more effective technique than drilling straight through. This bi-directional drilling created a distinctive hourglass-shaped hole that, as experimental archaeology would later prove, actually helped secure the wooden spindle in place.
![Spinning methods. (a) Manual thigh-spinning [64]; (b) Spindle-and-whorl “supported spinning” [68]; (c) “drop spinning” [66]; (d) the experimental spindles and whorls, the 3D scans of the pebbles and their negative perforations. The bottom pictures show Yonit Kristal experimenting spinning fibres with replicas of the perforated pebbles, using supported spinning and drop spinning techniques (photographed by Talia Yashuv).](https://studyfinds.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/wheels--1200x761.jpg)
To test their theory about these objects being spindle whorls, the researchers created replicas and enlisted the help of a traditional craft expert, Yonit Kristal. Using these reconstructed tools, they successfully spun both wool and flax into thread, though flax proved more effective. The experiments showed that while these ancient tools weren’t as efficient as modern spinning wheels, they represented a significant technological advancement over hand-spinning techniques.
This study, published in PLOS ONE, challenges our understanding of when humans first began experimenting with rotational technology. While the wheel-and-axle system is commonly associated with transportation in the Bronze Age (around 5,000 years ago), these spindle whorls show that humans were already manipulating rotational motion for practical purposes thousands of years earlier.
The implications extend beyond just textile production. These simple tools represent what researchers call “recombination” – the process by which existing technologies are combined in new ways to create innovations. The mechanical principle of the spindle whorl – a weighted disc rotating around a central axis – is essentially the same principle that would later be applied to potter’s wheels, water mills, and eventually, wheeled vehicles.
In a delightful twist of technological evolution, these ancient spindle whorls might be seen as the great-great-grandparents of not just modern spinning wheels but of all rotational technologies we use today. From the humble beginnings of spinning thread, humanity’s understanding of rotational motion would eventually revolutionize transportation, manufacturing, and countless other aspects of civilization. Who knew that the road to the wheel’s invention began not with a cart but with a simple stone and the desire for better thread?
Paper Summary
Methodology
The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to study these artifacts. They first used a structure-light scanner to create high-resolution 3D models of each stone. They developed special software to analyze both the complete shape of the stones and the internal structure of the holes. The team measured various parameters, including weight, center of mass, and hole dimensions. They also conducted practical experiments using replicas to test the functionality of these objects as spindle whorls.
Key Results
The study found that the stones were carefully selected for specific characteristics: most were soft limestone, relatively lightweight (averaging 9 grams), and had holes drilled precisely through their centers. The holes were predominantly created using a bi-directional drilling technique, creating a distinctive hourglass shape with a standardized minimum width of 3-4 millimeters. Experimental testing proved these objects could effectively function as spindle whorls for creating a thread.
Study Limitations
The study acknowledges that while use-wear analysis could provide additional evidence for how these objects were used, such analysis was beyond the scope of this research. The experimental testing was also limited in scope, focusing primarily on verifying basic functionality rather than exploring all possible variables in prehistoric spinning techniques.
Discussion & Takeaways
The research suggests that rotational technology emerged much earlier than previously thought, though in a different context than transportation. The study emphasizes how technological innovation often occurs through recombining existing knowledge in new ways. The findings challenge the traditional narrative of when humans first began experimenting with rotational motion and suggest a more complex evolution of wheel-based technologies.
Funding & Disclosures
The research was supported by Israel Science Foundation grants #2034/19 and #703/23, the Irene Levy Sala CARE Archaeological Foundation, and the Bina and Moshe Stekelis Foundation for prehistoric research in Israel. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.







