5 Top-Rated Frozen Pepperoni Pizzas To Try, According To Foodies

Are you in the mood for a pepperoni pizza but don’t feel like ordering takeout? That’s where frozen pizza can do the trick. Let’s face it, though, it can be hard to find a tasty — and, quite frankly, edible — frozen pepperoni pizza. That’s where StudyFinds comes in. We scoured through a trove of online experts and were able to compile a list of the top five best frozen pepperoni pizza brands.

It’s best to eat pizza in moderation, but a personal trainer from Northern Ireland claims he got into better shape eating ten slices of pizza a day. Ryan Mercer, 34, says he ate pizza for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and managed to lose roughly 7.7 pounds during the 30-day challenge. He took on the challenge to show how calorie-deficit diets allow people to lose weight without restricting their favorite foods. So, if you are determined to keep your calories in check, you may not have to give up pizza if you are trying to lose weight.

A separate study reveals that people can occasionally eat all the pizza they want without damaging their health. Researchers from the University of Bath finds people can eat much more than what normally makes them feel “full” without causing health problems. Scientists say young men are able to devour twice as much pizza when they push themselves. All you can eat pizza? Sign me up.

Are you in the mood for your favorite pie made right at home? StudyFinds has put together the top five best frozen pepperoni pizza consumers should opt for. Did we miss one of your favorites? Let us know in the comments below!

➡️ How Our “Best Of The Best” Lists Are Created

StudyFinds’ “Best of the Best” articles are put together with the idea of taking the work out of common consumer research. Ever find yourself searching for a product or service on Google and reading multiple reviews to find items listed across many of them? Our Best of the Best lists are created with that process in mind, with each item ranked by how frequently it appears on expert reviews or lists. With Best of the Best, you are getting consensus picks — making them truly the best of the best!

person slicing pizza
Slicing a pepperoni pizza (Photo by Rosalind Chang on Unsplash)

The List: Best Frozen Pepperoni Pizza, According to Experts

1. DiGiorno

DiGiorno's Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza
DiGiorno’s Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza (target.com)

Digiorno reigns supreme in the frozen pepperoni pizza arena, offering a variety of styles to satisfy diverse cravings. For thick-crust enthusiasts, The New York Times hails their Rising Crust Pepperoni as the champion. They praise its well-risen, flavorful crust with the perfect balance of crispness and chewiness. Even thin-crust fans commend its deliciousness and ability to support a hearty slice. The pepperoni itself is thin and abundant, adding a satisfying crunch.

Craving a crispy pan pizza? Look no further than DiGiorno’s Crispy Pan Pepperoni. Tasting Table applauds its caramelized crust, real mozzarella, and savory pepperoni, delivering a simple yet powerful flavor combination. They even declare it pizza perfection at home, potentially tempting you to ditch delivery.

But if you’re seeking pure indulgence, Delish suggests the Pepperoni Frozen Pizza with Croissant Crust. This innovative option incorporates the beloved layering of croissant dough, resulting in a thick, flaky crust that tasters rave about for its crispy texture and buttery richness.

2. Red Baron

Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Red Baron takes the second spot, catering to both budget-conscious and thin-crust lovers. The Takeout describes their classic pepperoni pizza as a nostalgic trip down memory lane, reminiscent of school cafeteria pizzas but elevated. While high in calories, it wins them over with its fragrant aroma, balanced toppings, and unbeatable price.

Sporked champions the Thin and Crispy Pepperoni for its surprisingly delicious take on Domino’s thin crust. They praise its buttery, cracker-like crust, flavorful sauce, and ample spicy pepperoni.

Finally, MyRecipes recommends the Brick Oven Pepperoni for its well-balanced combination of thick crust, cheese, and sauce. While the cheese wasn’t universally loved, everyone appreciated the generous pepperoni distribution and mildly sweet sauce, especially for the price. Overall, Red Baron offers solid options for those prioritizing affordability and familiar flavors, with both classic and thin-crust varieties to choose from.

3. Newman’s Own

Newman's Own All Natural Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni Pizza
Newman’s Own All Natural Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni Pizza (newmansown.com)

Newman’s Own All Natural Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni Pizza earns its spot among the top contenders for its stellar crust and high-quality pepperoni. Delish highlights its impressive crispness and substantial feel, while praising the “real thing” taste of the pepperoni.

BuzzFeed further emphasizes the pepperoni’s exceptional quality, calling it “exquisite” and lauding its perfect marbling, thickness, and meaty flavor without any greasiness.

Uproxx goes into the details, explaining how Newman’s Own uses a superior pork and beef blend for their pepperoni, setting it apart from many frozen pizzas that incorporate chicken in the mix. This commitment to quality ingredients shines through in the final product, making it a favorite for those seeking a delicious and authentic pepperoni pizza experience.

4. Freschetta

Freschetta Thin Crust Premium Pepperoni Pizza
Freschetta Thin Crust Premium Pepperoni Pizza

Freschetta nabs the fourth spot, appealing to many with its classic flavors and generous toppings. Hip2Save commends the balanced sweetness and savoriness of the sauce, ample toppings, and memorable crust texture and flavor.

The Takeout highlights their popular Naturally Rising Crust option, citing its absence from store shelves as a testament to its appeal. While they opted for the thin crust, praising its golden brown crispness, lightness, and adequate pepperoni, they acknowledge the focaccia-like base might not suit everyone.

MyRecipes delves deeper, noting the naturally-rising crust’s divisiveness due to its breadiness but acknowledging its visual appeal. Despite mixed feelings on the crust, tasters appreciated the generous mozzarella, provolone, and preservative-free pepperoni, even if a tad greasy. Overall, Freschetta offers a crowd-pleasing option with its familiar flavors and generous toppings, though the focaccia-like crust might not be for everyone.

5. Screamin’ Sicilian

Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza Co. Holy Pepperoni
Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza Co. Holy Pepperoni (target.com)

Screamin’ Sicilian takes the final spot and caters to those who crave a maximalist pepperoni experience. Both The New York Times and Sporked acknowledge the pizza’s impressive pepperoni overload, bordering on messy and oily for some. While the cheese gets praise for its flavor and texture, the thin crust, though well-seasoned, falls short compared to fresh pizza.

Sporked emphasizes the nostalgic arcade pizza vibes and sheer indulgence factor, recommending Tums for the aftermath. Uproxx positions it as a delicious frozen alternative to national chains, though not quite a substitute for a genuine pizzeria slice. Overall, Screamin’ Sicilian offers a flavor bomb for true pepperoni lovers, but be prepared for its richness and potential messiness.


Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links in which we receive a commission if you make a purchase.

Follow on Google News

About the Author

Matt Higgins

Matt Higgins worked in national and local news for 15 years. He started out as an overnight production assistant at Fox News Radio in 2007 and ended in 2021 as the Digital Managing Editor at CBS Philadelphia. Following his news career, he spent one year in the automotive industry as a Digital Platforms Content Specialist contractor with Subaru of America and is currently a freelance writer and editor for StudyFinds. Matt believes in facts, science and Philadelphia sports teams crushing his soul.

The contents of this website do not constitute advice and are provided for informational purposes only. See our full disclaimer


  1. Authentic Motor City Pizza Co. Detroit Style Deep Dish Pizza is the best pizza in my book, I usually throw leftover pizza away after a few days, but that never happens with this pizza, it’s delicious warmed up as well. Yummy!

Comments are closed.