The Best Hotels In Key West: Top 5 Places To Stay Most Recommended By Experts

Key West is a famous place at the southernmost point of the United States. This place is famous for its fantastic nightlife, beautiful beaches, and rich culture. If you’re considering staying at this lovely place for a vacation, go on! All you need to do is find one of the best hotels in Key West that meets your needs.

Do you love watching sunsets? Then Key West is the best location to visit. It topped our list as the best place in the world for watching sunsets. It also is the number one best vacation spot for couples on our list. Part of the stunning Florida Keys, Key West is a beautiful, secluded island ideal for a romantic weekend trip.

Speaking of romance, a vacation can do a lot for a couple lost in the choas of life instead of each other’s eyes. A recent study surveying 2,000 adults looked at the magic of vacationing – especially with others – and found that three-quarters of respondents believe vacations are great for those looking to keep the spark alive in their relationship (77%). Also, 42 percent of participants rekindled their flame while traveling.

To catch a dazzling sunset or bring on the romance, Key West is a travel destination filled with gorgeous beaches, resorts, and hotels to make your stay marvelous. StudyFinds selected the five best hotels in Key West after going through 10 expert sites for anyone considering booking an exquisite trip. 

green and white beach signage
(Photo by Jametlene Reskp on Unsplash)

The List: Best Hotels in Key West, According to Experts

1. Ocean Key Resort and Spa

10 Best likes its convenient location between Key West Harbor and Mallory Square.  “Ocean Key Resort & Spa is the epitome of barefoot elegance. Their spacious rooms and suites offer understated tropical decor and luxurious comfort like whirlpool tubs and their own Spa Terre bath products. Spend your days at LIQUID, their private pool, bar and lounge or head to the colorful Sunset Pier for casual dining and drinks. Don’t miss their popular weekend brunch with unlimited mimosas and bloody Marys.”

“Its prime location at the top end of Duval Street has led to Ocean Key Resort & Spa having what is probably the most sought after address in Florida: 0 Duval Street, Key West. Little surprise, then, that this extremely elegant resort in Key West is as close to the city’s best entertainment and dining action,” says PlanetWare. “Not that you’d ever need to leave this classy 4-star luxury resort. Ocean Key offers everything from world-class, gourmet dining in its Hot Tin Roof restaurant to plenty of pampering at its full-service spa, SpaTerre. For a truly memorable and romantic experience, be sure to try the couple’s massage.”

Time Out writes of its breathtaking views: “The vibrant Ocean Key Resort and Spa is perfect for those looking for a hotel slap bang in the middle of the action. The resort overlooks the Gulf of Mexico and every room has a panoramic view of the water. Don’t pass up the hotel’s ‘Sunny Side Up’ promotion, where breakfast is served daily on your private balcony. The resort also offers Florida residents discounted rates for those planning a staycation in their own backyard.”

2. Casa Marina Key West

Trip Savvy mentions notable guests at this hotel such as Ernest Hemingway and Helen Mirren. “The art deco landmark was designed by the same architects behind the New York Public Library and holds a spot on the National Register of Historic Places. Accommodations are sparsely decorated, but the majority boast large picture windows and ocean views. The crown jewel of the property is the 1,100-foot private beach that it sits on, the largest in Key West. Guests also can relax by two outdoor pools where they’ll be spoiled with full service, including eucalyptus towels and popsicles that are brought around to sunbathers.”

The Telegraph writes, “Genuine Florida can still be found – with the addition of all mod cons – in a quiet corner of Key West, ensuring a sophisticated and history-tinged stay in one of the city’s signature architectural highlights that has been beautifully maintained over the years to uphold the Gilded Age heritage of its creator.”

“A beachfront hotel landmark conceived by railroad tycoon Henry Flagler, Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton dates back to the glamorous 1920s. Soak up elegance and grandeur that has attracted the likes of dignitaries and the crème de la crème for nearly a century. Take in the stunningly redone lobby, two great pools, and a lovely beach,” explains Southern Living

3. Parrot Key Hotel and Villas

Insider says this newly refurbished hotel lands you the best value. “The rooms and suites feature three different views: garden, garden/water, and waterfront, and every glance is a feast for the eyes, especially if you’re facing the Gulf of Mexico. The inside is soothing as well, with breezy textiles in shades of whites and neutrals, which makes for a pleasant canvas next to all the outdoor colors. Conch-inspired artwork completes the Key West charm. While a standard Garden King or Double Queen begins at $239 in the off-season, I suggest booking a Garden Suite or a Waterfront King for a minimal extra investment.”

“Nestled among Florida Bay, just a short drive from Key West, the stunning Parrot Key Hotel features stunning views, a fitness center, a restaurant, and a bar for guest entertainment,” writes Travellers Worldwide. “Guests can also enjoy free private parking, nearby kayaking, a relaxing onsite massage, or going for a ride on the complimentary shuttle bus to discover all the historic center of Key West has to offer. Hotel rooms feature a flat-screen TV, a mini-fridge, a comfortable bed, and a private terrace with lush tropical views.”

“The verdant grounds have four pools; the resort’s rooms, suites, and villas, meanwhile, all have views of the gardens. Even the entry-level rooms span 375 square feet and receive loads of light, which accents the neutral gray and tan decor,” adds Conde Nast Traveler

4. The Marquesa Hotel

Forbes says that it is the best boutique hotel. “There are just 27 rooms inside four restored conch cottages dating back to the late 1800s with tin roofs, pastel siding and white wraparound balconies. The lushly landscaped grounds, including two secluded swimming pools shaded by palm fronds, induce even the most harried travelers to rest and relax. Spacious rooms, including standard rooms, balcony rooms and suites, have Brazilian cherry hardwood floors and antique reproduction furnishings sourced from the West Indies and the Philippines and modern bathrooms.”

Insider boasts about their amenities: “The resort offers three pools, which you have access to wherever you stay, lots of wicker, and airy, colorful fabrics, as well as updated bathrooms. Although a standard Queen in the main house with a city view is perfectly delightful, I suggest upgrading to the more private, fresher rooms such as a Balcony Deluxe with a King bed, private covered balcony, two lounge chairs, and a table.”

“Tropical hideaway? Check. Close to the attractions and temptations of Key West’s Old Town? Check. Boutique style and accommodations? Check. Award-winning restaurant? Check. Sense of personal refinement amid a lively, non-stop location? Double-check. If all of those are on your wish list, welcome to the Marquesa Hotel,” notes The Telegraph.

5. Sunset Key Cottages

According to 10 Best, this is the ultimate getaway on the secluded 27-acre island of Sunset Key, accessible by a short ferry ride. “Dotted with 40 two-, three- and four-bedroom cottages, this recent addition to the Luxury Collection is laced with footpaths leading to private beaches, fitness center, two tennis courts, basketball court and zero-degree entry pool. The well-appointed cottages capture the essence on Conch architecture with porches, pastel wood finishes and Victorian-style tin roofs. Guests are welcomed by the resort’s signature cocktail, frozen-sweet treats and personal concierge service. Each morning a breakfast basket, packed with freshly baked muffins, orange juice and a newspaper are delivered to your porch.”

“The buildings are surrounded by nothing but lush gardens loaded with frangipani, sand, and turquoise blue waters, making the resort a secluded sanctuary. Rooms are perfectly beachy, but some cottages are more modern than others,” writes Conde Nast Traveler. “The bath amenity game is spot-on here, too, and water views are virtually unobstructed.”

“Enjoy the resort’s very own exclusive beach, lounge by the pool, book an excursion on the water, or unwind at the spa. For those who like to remain active, there’s a 24-hour gym in addition to beach yoga on Saturday mornings and two tennis courts. While you easily can hop into town for a bite via the property’s private launch, don’t miss out on a delectable meal highlighting locally sourced seafood at the property’s award-winning Latitudes, where you can also enjoy a complimentary rum tasting every afternoon,” raves Trip Savvy

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Check out these latest Beach Destination Deals from Orbitz and book your getaway to paradise before it’s too late!

You might also be interested in:


Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This post may contain affiliate links.

Follow on Google News

About the Author

Saloni Ordia

Saloni is a freelance B2B SaaS writer who excels at creating in-depth product-focused content. When she is not writing, you can find her in the kitchen whipping up new recipes or curled up with a rom-com novel.

The contents of this website do not constitute advice and are provided for informational purposes only. See our full disclaimer


  1. Who paid you to write this? Casa Marina Key West is a joke. The guest rooms are horrible, moldy, and falling apart.

Comments are closed.