5 Best Earl Grey Teas To Sip On, According To Consumer Reviews

Earl Grey tea, known for its distinctive flavor and fragrant aroma, has been a beloved choice among enthusiasts for centuries. With its origins tracing back to the 19th century, this classic black tea infused with bergamot oil continues to captivate taste buds around the world. As the popularity of Earl Grey tea soars, the market is flooded with a wide range of options, making it a daunting task for tea lovers to choose the best among them. This is why today we will delve into the realm of the best Earl Grey teas and present a curated list of the finest blends available, ensuring that tea enthusiasts make an informed choice. 

Overall, Earl Grey’s unique flavor, versatility, and health benefits make it a strong contender for the title of “best tea flavor.” As always, we at StudyFinds have researched across 10 expert sources to bring you today’s ranking of the top five best Earl Grey tea brands for your enjoyment. Don’t agree with our list or feel we missed out on a good suggestion? We would love to hear from you in the comments down below. 

cup of coffee and biscuits on tray
Earl Grey Tea (Photo by Priscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash)

The List: Best Earl Grey Tea Most Recommended By Experts

1. Adagio Teas

Earl Grey by Adagio Teas
Earl Grey by Adagio Teas

Calling all tea lovers! If you’re looking for a classic cup of Earl Grey, look no further than Adagio Earl Grey. This tea has been a crowd-pleaser for centuries, and for good reason. The unique combination of flavor and aroma makes it a favorite among tea connoisseurs around the world. Life is Better With Tea suggests Adagio’s Earl Grey as a great place to start your bergamot exploration. They love the full-leaf loose tea packaged in convenient individual pouches, perfect for a fresh and flavorful cup every time.

Food 52 describes the Adagio Earl Grey as a calming and understated tea experience. They mention the light and sweet black tea base with subtle citrus notes, reminiscent of a soothing pre-spa treatment sip.

2. Twinings

Twinings Earl Grey
Twinings Earl Grey

Steep yourself in tradition with a cup of Twinings Earl Grey, a tea that’s been a beloved beverage for centuries, according to reviewers who rave about its classic flavor and English charm. Elfin View says it’s a must-try for Earl Grey enthusiasts, praising its perfect balance of bergamot and premium black tea from Assam and Ceylon – a true representation of the English style.

But Twinings Earl Grey isn’t just about heritage; it’s about creating an experience. Sporked describes it as the ideal tea to sip while enveloped in a luxurious robe, the kind that makes you feel instantly posh. They mention the mild flavor and slightly sleepy vibe (despite the caffeine!), making it perfect for winding down in the evening. It’s a tea that whispers relaxation, perfect for a calming end to the day.

And for those who forgo caffeine but still crave the taste of Earl Grey, fear not! All Recipes says Twinings offers a decaf version that doesn’t disappoint. While the black tea base might be lighter than some prefer, the bergamot flavor shines through beautifully. This creates a delightful and citrusy decaf Earl Grey that allows everyone to enjoy a cup of this classic tea.

3. Bigelow

Bigelow Earl Grey
Bigelow Earl Grey

Earl Grey drinkers, rejoice! Bigelow Earl Grey is a timeless blend that’s been captivating tea lovers for generations, according to reviewers who appreciate its quality and affordability. Named after a British Prime Minister with a penchant for good taste (Charles Grey, the 2nd Earl Grey, to be exact), this tea is renowned for its distinctive citrusy aroma and flavor.

Food 52 mentions that the bergamot notes are subtle in the Bigelow Earl Grey. They liken it more to an English Breakfast tea, but with a budget-friendly price tag. This makes it a perfect choice for those who go through a lot of tea throughout the day (and don’t want to break the bank fueling their tea habit!).

Elfin View chimes in, praising the Bigelow family for their dedication to quality tea blends. They describe Bigelow’s Earl Grey as a full-bodied black tea with just the right amount of bergamot oil, resulting in a robust and classic Earl Grey flavor. And for those who love the taste but want to ditch the caffeine, Elfin View mentions Bigelow also offers a decaf version – perfect for enjoying a cup of Earl Grey any time of day.

4. Harney & Sons

Harney & Sons Earl Grey Imperial
Harney & Sons Earl Grey Imperial

Harney & Sons Earl Grey is a delightful tea that is loved by tea enthusiasts around the world. Food 52 describes it as a complex and bold Earl Grey experience, like a warm hug on a wintery day. They love the addition of white tea to the traditional black tea and bergamot oil blend, mentioning it creates a more nuanced flavor profile perfect for sipping by a crackling fire. And for those who appreciate aesthetics, Food 52 can’t resist mentioning Harney & Sons’ beautiful old-fashioned tins – a lovely touch that makes this tea a perfect gift.

Elfin View also mentions the brand’s commitment to quality and sustainability. Their Earl Grey is a classic black tea infused with bergamot oil, but they source their black tea leaves directly from trusted plantations. This translates to a more environmentally-conscious choice for those who prefer organic and fair-trade tea products.

Finally, Professional Tea Taster chimes in, applauding the exceptional fragrance of Harney & Sons Earl Grey. They mention that while they tend to favor single-origin teas, Harney & Sons’ blended teas consistently impress. In the case of their Earl Grey Imperial Tea, they especially love the robust and fragrant bergamot oil, a quality that many Earl Grey enthusiasts seek.

5. Numi

Numi Aged Earl Grey
Numi Aged Earl Grey

Numi Earl Grey is a tea that embodies the essence of elegance and sophistication. Made from a blend of fine black tea and the essence of bergamot, this exquisite tea is a true delight for the senses. Food 52 describes it as a classic Earl Grey experience done right. The bright citrus notes from the bergamot oil dance beautifully with the soothing black tea base, creating a flavor profile that’s both invigorating and calming. For those who appreciate quality ingredients, Numi delivers. They use only the finest black tea leaves, ensuring a satisfying and authentic Earl Grey experience.

Sporked adds that Numi’s commitment goes beyond the cup. They love that Numi prioritizes ethical sourcing, fair trade practices, organic ingredients, and remains non-GMO. So you can sip your tea guilt-free, knowing you’re doing your part for the environment while enjoying a delicious cuppa.

If you prefer your Earl Grey on the subtler side of citrus, Pique Life recommends Numi as a perfect choice. Their organic and Fair Trade Earl Grey features black tea leaves sourced from the Assam region of India, known for its robust flavor. The bergamot oil, sourced from real Italian bergamots, is carefully aged with the tea leaves. This slow and meticulous process allows the tea to absorb the citrus aroma and flavor gently, resulting in a well-balanced cup with a hint of orange that won’t overpower your taste buds.


Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This article may contain affiliate links in which we receive a commission if you make a purchase.

Follow on Google News

About the Author

Jilly Hite

New York raised and Florida-based Jilly Hite studied screenwriting and theatre at The Lee Strasberg Institute before becoming a full time content creator and podcaster. She loves old movies, musical theatre, and her pup Ted.

The contents of this website do not constitute advice and are provided for informational purposes only. See our full disclaimer