Best Pumpkin Syrup: Top 3 Fall Flavorings Most Recommended By Experts

When fall arrives, many of us eagerly anticipate the return of pumpkin spice everything. From lattes to pancakes, one of the key ingredients that makes these delightful autumn treats possible is pumpkin spice syrup. The market is flooded with various brands and recipes offering their takes on this seasonal staple. So, to help you find the very best pumpkin syrup for your taste buds, we’ve done some syrup-sipping research.

After all, this topic may be the most important of the year, as a OnePoll study revealed the overall favorite season of the people they surveyed is autumn. Why? Sixty-nine percent saying that this time of year has the best seasonal flavors. And of all the flavors, pumpkin spice is just so nice because it strikes a perfect balance of cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, and ginger, making it a versatile add-in for coffees, cocktails, and baked goods. 

While most pumpkin spiced offerings are an absolute delight, they’re often not the healthiest on the menu. But here’s the thing – it’s not the pumpkin itself that’s the issue; it’s all those added sugars, fats and whatnot that sneak in. What most people don’t realize is that pumpkin is a legit nutritional powerhouse, and it’s totally worth keeping it in your diet all year long! 

But not all tasty seasonal syrups are created equal. The best pumpkin spice syrup brands often offer versatile flavor that can be used in various recipes beyond your morning coffee. From drizzling it over waffles to adding a touch of fall to your homemade desserts, a delicious syrup can truly elevate your autumn. So, whether you’re a pumpkin spice latte enthusiast or a creative cook looking for that perfect fall ingredient, there’s a pumpkin spice syrup out there waiting to spice up your season. Did we miss your favorite? Let us know in the comments below!

Pancakes with pumpkin syrup
Pancakes with pumpkin syrup (Photo by Ash on Pexels)

The List: Best Pumpkin Syrups, According to Flavor Experts


1. Torani Pumpkin Spice Syrup

With almost a century of experience and a commitment to natural ingredients and allergen-free formulations, Torani syrup is a top choice for your pumpkin spice cravings. The brand itself says, “There’s a reason it’s a holiday favorite. Cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves swim together in a robust pumpkin-flavored syrup. The warmth of the holidays comes through in whatever you make.”

Torani Pumpkin Spice Syrup
Torani Pumpkin Spice Syrup

And as for the experts, Tartelette recommends this brand if you’re going to be your own barista. “Made using natural flavors and pure cane sugar, Torani’s pumpkin spice syrup is very popular. It’s great as a seasonal additive to coffees and hot chocolate. Some find the spice flavors of this syrup more subtle, so if you’re looking for a softer flavoring, this is the one for you.”

BestReviews has this as their number one pick, saying, “This syrup comes from one of the best brands in the game. It contains no artificial preservatives, colors or flavors. You can buy it as a single 25.4-fluid-ounce bottle or as a pack of four bottles of the same capacity.” 

Even this brand’s sugar-free option is top-notch. According to Best Coffee Syrup, it’s “fall flavor without the guilt.” Their review states, “We liked this syrup for its overall taste — less spice, more pumpkin! Great for mixing into protein shakes, lattes or for baking.” 

2. Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup

If you’re looking to replicate the magic of pumpkin spice lattes at home, Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup is a highly recommended choice. It goes a little beyond just the spice by throwing in a whole pie full of flavors. Monin says it “combines warm, decadent pumpkin with baked crust crumbles and a dash of cinnamon.” Yum!

Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup
Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup

The Cup Coffee House compares this syrup to Starbucks’, writing, “Starbucks, unfortunately, doesn’t sell its [pumpkin spice] syrup to the public. However, we compared the ingredients in Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Sauce to other syrups and found a close cousin in Monin Pumpkin Pie Syrup. Like Starbucks’ PSL, this Monin coffee syrup includes real pumpkin puree, cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger.” 

Landing in the top place of their pumpkin syrup picks, Truly Experiences says, “Pumpkin spice lattes are a very seasonal thing in chain coffee shops … but if you’re a really big fan, then the chance to recreate them at home all year round will be a welcome option.” And why not welcome the fall flavor favorite home with Monin?  

For some people, like those who are vegans, Starbucks may not even be an option for pumpkin spice deliciousness since their syrup contains dairy! But Evening Standard likes this milk-free brand, writing, “The Pumpkin Spice blend is a fan-favourite, consisting of sweet pumpkin, spicy clove and cinnamon. Suitable for vegans and certifiably both Kosher and Halal, this syrup is as good as it gets.” 

3. Jordan’s Skinny Mixes Sugar-Free Pumpkin Spice Coffee Flavoring Syrup

This brand is well-known for its pumpkin spice syrup, and it’s a popular pick among the experts below. Its no wonder why when Jordans Skinny Mixes describes it as a way to “add guilt-free flavor to coffees, lattes, tea, protein shakes, smoothies, baking, oatmeal or just about anything.”  

Jordan’s Skinny Mixes Sugar-Free Pumpkin Spice Coffee Flavoring Syrup
Jordan’s Skinny Mixes Sugar-Free Pumpkin Spice Coffee Flavoring Syrup writes, “Enjoy the pumpkin flavor without added sugar with this highly rated pick on Amazon.” And when they say highly-rated, they mean it! It has more than 88,000 reviews! 

Baby Bargains even put this syrup to the test against other brands: “To find the best-tasting options, we did a blind taste test with pumpkin spice coffee aficionados. For the best sugar-free pumpkin spice syrup, the winner was Jordan’s Skinny Mixes. And this syrup not only tasted good, it was also easy on the wallet.”

So, as you embrace the flavors of fall, we hope this list of the top three expert-recommended pumpkin syrups helps you spice up your season! 

You might also be interested in:


Note: This article was not paid for nor sponsored. StudyFinds is not connected to nor partnered with any of the brands mentioned and receives no compensation for its recommendations. This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *